|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 11 post(s) |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
50
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 17:04:00 -
[1] - Quote
Its not hard to balance Ishtars. Limit their drone connection range. So they have to stay near their sentries in order to stay connected to them. This will eliminate the current meta of dropping sentries and retreating away. If the ship has to stay close to its drones, it reduces their mobility which makes them easier to kill.
20km range max. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
50
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 17:14:00 -
[2] - Quote
sten mattson wrote:weird idea:
maybe make sentries follow the mothership and shoot its target while moving? i.e they always follow the ishtar while shooting its primary
that way the ishtar will always be close to its drones and he will have to care about tracking again
Nah, rather the Ishtar have to remain in range to stay connected. Say 20km max or it loses connection with the sentries. Make their scoop/return range 10km. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
50
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 17:21:00 -
[3] - Quote
Make drone ship also lose connection to its drones/sentries if jammed by ECM and/or Sensor Damps. That on top of a max range to maintain active connection to drones/sentries would balance sentries and drone boats all around. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
50
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 17:30:00 -
[4] - Quote
Gizznitt Malikite wrote:Altirius Saldiaro wrote:Make drone ship also lose connection to its drones/sentries if jammed by ECM and/or Sensor Damps. That on top of a max range to maintain active connection to drones/sentries would balance sentries and drone boats all around. One thing I was really annoyed with: ECM Bursts seems to not effect drones effectively. This should be changed so an ECM burst causes a drone to lose all locks and then aggro based on CCP's wonky drone aggro AI.
Yeah. Why should a drone ship be immune to ecm/damps and not lose connection to their drones?
People bitched about afk ratting and mission running, but rats do use ewar. Their ewar should affect the ship's connection with its drones.
Stargate Universe. There was an enemy that used drones. The crew of the Destiny managed to fight by jamming the drone ship, which rendered the drones inert until the drone ship could break the jam. It was great and made sense. I want that in EVE. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
52
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 17:54:00 -
[5] - Quote
Harvey James wrote:Altirius Saldiaro wrote:Gizznitt Malikite wrote:Altirius Saldiaro wrote:Make drone ship also lose connection to its drones/sentries if jammed by ECM and/or Sensor Damps. That on top of a max range to maintain active connection to drones/sentries would balance sentries and drone boats all around. One thing I was really annoyed with: ECM Bursts seems to not effect drones effectively. This should be changed so an ECM burst causes a drone to lose all locks and then aggro based on CCP's wonky drone aggro AI. Yeah. Why should a drone ship be immune to ecm/damps and not lose connection to their drones? People bitched about afk ratting and mission running, but rats do use ewar. Their ewar should affect the ship's connection with its drones. Stargate Universe. There was an enemy that used drones. The crew of the Destiny managed to fight by jamming the drone ship, which rendered the drones inert until the drone ship could break the jam. It was great and made sense. I want that in EVE. indeed .. if a drone needs its parent ship too function then why does it not need a constant connection ??? surely any interruption like ecm or damps should render them idle..
Would be a more basic balance to all drone ships too. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
53
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 19:09:00 -
[6] - Quote
Querns wrote:MeBiatch wrote:To balance the ishtar I would greatly reduce the target range by 1/3 or to 52.8km. That way if you want to take advantage of the senty range you have to use sensor boosters. Ishtars will just assign their drones to someone with longer target range.
If ECM and Damps affected a ship's connection with its drones, then it couldnt assign their drones because they'd lose ability to command their drones.
Ewar is the key to balancing OP sentry boats. EWAR needs to affect the connection between ship and its drones. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
55
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 19:17:00 -
[7] - Quote
Not only should ecm break connection with the drones/sentires, but a Tracking Disruptor should affect the ship's drones/sentries as well. If a module on my ishtar can increase the tracking speed or optimal eange of my drones, then enemy tracking disruption hitting my ship should also affect my drones/sentry tracking. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
55
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 19:24:00 -
[8] - Quote
Harvey James wrote:Altirius Saldiaro wrote:Not only should ecm break connection with the drones/sentires, but a Tracking Disruptor should affect the ship's drones/sentries as well. If a module on my ishtar can increase the tracking speed or optimal eange of my drones, then enemy tracking disruption hitting my ship should also affect my drones/sentry tracking. I agree along with other changes this could help alleviate the ishtar domination
At least its not just a hands down nerf to just one ship because everyone uses it. It gives pilots the ability to counter. Its what ECM means, counter measure. Why the ingame counter measures dont already affect drones is beyond my understanding. That should have been a part of EVE a long time ago. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
55
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 19:49:00 -
[9] - Quote
Sara Tosa wrote:Altirius Saldiaro wrote:Querns wrote:MeBiatch wrote:To balance the ishtar I would greatly reduce the target range by 1/3 or to 52.8km. That way if you want to take advantage of the senty range you have to use sensor boosters. Ishtars will just assign their drones to someone with longer target range. If ECM and Damps affected a ship's connection with its drones, then it couldnt assign their drones because they'd lose ability to command their drones. Ewar is the key to balancing OP sentry boats. EWAR needs to affect the connection between ship and its drones. maybe sentries, if regular drones get immobile becouse ewar they'll get instakilled then the ship (now we arent' talking about ishtar anymore) lose its only weapon. ewar should be temporary, not a permanent weapon denial.
Balancing ewar is a separate topic. Making ewar affect drones just makes too much sense for ccp to implement. There is ECCM which is the counter to ECM. So ecm is not permanent. It can be if you're fitted to make it highly effective. But there are still counters in game for that. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
55
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 20:10:00 -
[10] - Quote
"maybe I didnt explain myself, sorry - not native english. when a drone ship drop connection to its drones, those will stop and become immobile targets - easily blapped by anybody, the only defence a small or even medium drone has is when its orbiting its target. so if ewar do the same it basically means singleshotting all the droneship weapons."
So be it. I'm ok with that. I should have to fit my ship to prevent losing connection with my drones.
When I am flying my Apoc in missions, and I get tracking disrupted, damped or ecm'd, it affects my ship's effectiveness. I dont complain about it. I fit my ship to compensate the best I can. However, if I use a Domi, Ishtar or Armageddon, ewar does not affect the effectiveness of my drones/sentries. They keep shooting and tearing through targets, even though I cant target the rats or my guns cant track. So why is it ok for ewar to affect my ship but it doesn't affect my drones? To me, making ewar hitting my ship affect my drones is common sense, but then why call it common sense when its not so common? |
|

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
55
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 20:26:00 -
[11] - Quote
Shilalasar wrote:If the tracking on sentries was so bad the counter to Ishtars is to orbit the sentries? That sounds wrong. About as good of an idea as smartbombing them off with 0 m/s battleships. CCP Rise wrote:Sentry drones have enormous downsides. They can be killed like other drones AND they don't return to your ship. There's a reason they were never used at all until assist + these tracking/optimal bonuses came along. I am fairly certain someone at CCP took a hard nerfbat to every doctrine that was used before the Ishtar got buffed like crazy. Have not seen any supercaps with normal drones, trackingtitans, canes or drakes lately. Also DDAs weren-Št a thing. Or ships warping with different speeds. Pretty sure there was no real cruiserdoctrine except zealots for quite a while. The Ishtar is a broken peace of ****, with more fittingroom than most HACs. You can put whatever you want on it without requiring fittingmods. While not needing any CPU/PG for guns and still having free highslots. And as many people have pointed out destroyable only counts in largescale and without the ability to carry more than enough of them around and then even being able to reload from the cargohold.
Thats what they do. They go the lazy route. Everyone in null used drake blobs, so they nerfed drakes. Meanwhile, it affected the game play of everyone who loved using the drake or nonblobs. I loved the drake. Used to be my favorite ship to mission with. Now it sucks.
Players need to come up with doctrines that counter whatever. If thrre is no counter, then ccp should either buff something to become the counter or look at development of something that can become a counter. I keep suggesting in here to make ewar affect the relationship between the drone ship and the drones. It doesnt nerf the stats of the ship, it gives other players a way to counter that ship if they choose to use that counter measure. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
55
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 20:43:00 -
[12] - Quote
Drones are drones. They should not have their own AI. They should rely on their ship.
Because if I warp off grid, why dont my drones continue to shoot targets? Why the hell does that logic not apply when my ship is being hit with ewar? |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
56
|
Posted - 2014.07.29 23:30:00 -
[13] - Quote
Karash Amerius wrote:How about we just add some sort of visual overlay or addition to the overview that signifies which ship has the drones assigned to it? That way FCs can disrupt the command and control better.
Just white boarding here.
Why does it have to be so complex?
EWAR should affect the ship which should affect it's drones. It so damn simple. ECM a ship, it loses connection with its drones. Tracking Disrupt a ship, the tracking of its dromes are affected. Sensor Damp a ship, its drones sensors should be damped.
EWAR onto an enemy ship needs to affect it's drones. Basic and simple concept.
Whats the counter that the drone ships can use?? ECCM. Takes up midslots. Its effective. Even skills to increase racialnsensor strength.
The game already has the answer built right into the game. Counter Measures. CCP just needs to get with it and make the ewar carry from the ship to its drones. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
59
|
Posted - 2014.07.30 19:29:00 -
[14] - Quote
Callic Veratar wrote:I like the idea of ewar having an effect on drones. Right now, damps are basically the only thing that does anything if you damp all of the Ishtars, which really isn't reasonable in a large fight.
A few things have popped into my head:
- Target Spectrum Breaker disrupts all locked drones for 20s - ECM Burst disrupts all affected drones for 20s - Sensor Damps reduce drone control range in addition to target lock range (with additional drone lock script)
I got tired of repeating myself on this yesterday back in earlier pages. Good to see someone else bring up ewar.
Ewar just makes sense. It doesnt directly nerf just one ship. It gives players the option to use as a counter measure.
Omni Directional tracking links improve my drones tracking. Why does that bonus still apply to my drones when I am ECM jammed? Or if I am tracking disrupted, that should affect my drones.
The lack of logic on how drone upgrades are done is ridiculous without ewar affecting it. Why can I even communicate with my drones if I am ECM jammed? Why can I tell them to assist my friend that isnt jammed? Why can I even tell my drones to return if Im jammed. It shouldn't work that way.
Im not in favor of nerfing a ship or weapon system just because its the flavor of the month. I am completely in favor of CCP giving the players the tools we can choose to use to counter that popular ship being used. |

Altirius Saldiaro
Royal Amarr Institute Amarr Empire
59
|
Posted - 2014.07.30 19:58:00 -
[15] - Quote
Deacon Abox wrote:There have already been nerfs to sentries and now to the Ishtar. Still the Ishtar problem if there is one is nothing like the Drake problem of old. Anyway, further nerfage is misguided at this point. Sentry usage does come with not insignificant drawbacks.
The only thing that makes some sense in this discussion is possibly some ewar countering to drone use. But to simply thorw another ability onto ecm jammers and ecm boats would ruin the currently and very welcome damping down of ecm power (after many years "of Falcon"). The devs have stated they wanted to do something with painters (buff) and rework of ecm (change this horrible mechanic).
To throw some drone control counter ability to painters would make some sense now that Amarr use drones heavily. Say somehow the painted ship overloads the drone control communications and reduces tracking or range on the drones, or reduces the drone control range. Whatever, as long as the effect is not totally disabling (as with ecm).
Alternately, further nerf ecm, but give caldari recons a new anti drone control module.
But I really think this should go to Minmatar painters. Ecm can stay as it is, as horrid as it is, because it has been nerfed already to some semblance of tolerability. Painters however are such weak sauce that buffing them with anti-drone effects would give them more reason to be fit, and give the Vigil some reason to be on the battlefield.
There are counters to ewar. Eccm, remote sebos, remote eccm, warp core stabs, skills to increase sensor strength etc. |
|
|
|